Wednesday, February 24, 2010


It's been said that this pie is "to die for" -- I'm not sure about that, but it is "to die-t after"!
If the link to the printable version doesn't work for you, just go ahead and copy and paste the picture and the recipe to a Word Document...that works just as good. the recipe to your recipe files on your computer.

You do have recipes files on your computer....right?

Soft Custard Pie

30 Graham Crackers, crushed   (to crush use food processor or place in Ziploc bag and roll with rolling pin)
½ cup sugar
½ cup butter

Melt butter and add to crushed graham crackers and sugar.  Stir to combine.
Place in 10 inch pie plate and press into plate using another pie plate.
You may have enough crust for another small pie.

½ cup sugar
4 Tablespoons Corn Starch
5 egg yolks, save egg whites for meringue.  Be careful to not get any yolk in with whites.
Pinch Salt
1 quart milk
1 teaspoon vanilla

Put sugar, salt and cornstarch in 4 qt. saucepan and stir to mix.
Add egg yolks – then slowly add milk as you slowly stir.
Bring mixture slowly to a boil and stir until thickened.
Add vanilla.
Carefully add to graham cracker crust.

5 egg whites
10 Tablespoons sugar
¼ teaspoon cream of tartar

Beat egg whites while slowly adding sugar and cream of tartar.
This will take a few minutes. 
Beat until soft peaks form when beaters are pulled up from whites.

Carefully spoon (I use large spoon) egg whites onto custard, then spread to edges.  Use back of spoon to make peaks.

Bake at 375 -400 (depends on your oven)
10 to 12 minutes.

Cool and enjoy.
Keep refrigerated.

For a printable version of this recipe click Here


  1. Anonymous9:22 AM CST

    Thanks for the recipe! Sounds as good as you described.

  2. Anonymous10:04 AM CST

    You need to stop posting these yummy looking recipes!!! :) Landen and I are going on 6 weeks of eating "right" and man oh man does that pie look SOO GOOD!!!!


    P.S.- Has Cara informed you that we are dragging you to Zumba with us the Wednesday that you are here? :) You better be ready for some booty shaking and hip rolling!! And silliness of course!!


Stop back to read my response :)
Your comment may not appear right away.